Open Account Apply for a Loan
Make a Loan Payment Check Loan App 

Fitzsimons Credit Union


Fitzsimons Credit Union blog

Can You Save Thousands of Dollars by Buying a New Car With a Loan Instead of Cash?

by Victoria Simons
Published on September 8, 2015

Americans aren’t bashful when it comes to borrowing money to buy a car. About 85% of buyers take out a loan to pay for their new ride, according to Experian Automotive. But suppose you have enough saved up to pay in cash — is that the smartest move? Or does financing the purchase with today’s low interest rates and investing your money in the stock market make more sense?

To answer those questions, NerdWallet crunched the numbers for a hypothetical consumer: A buyer with enough savings to spend $25,000 on a F-150 XL pickup, which is part of the Ford F-Series, the best-selling line of vehicles in the U.S. In our scenario, the buyer would spend $5,000 of the money in the savings account on the truck and take out a $20,000 five-year loan at a 2% APR to cover the rest. When looking for a loan, be sure to shop around for the best APR — credit unions will often provide the lowest rates.

A potential payoff

The buyer’s remaining $20,000 would be invested in an index fund that tracks Standard & Poor’s 500 index, which has a 10-year annualized rate of return of 7.7% as of July. The buyer would then take money out of the index fund each month to make payments on the auto loan. 

Check Out NerdWallet’s Auto Loans Guide

So where does that leave the buyer? After paying the final loan installment and factoring in capital gains taxes, the buyer could be left with about $2,723 in the fund, or an 11% savings on the price of the new pickup.

Via: NerdWallet

A few words of warning

Not everybody can afford to pay for a new car in cash. And even for those who can, the peace of mind that comes with being debt-free may be more valuable than the potential payoff of taking out a loan and investing in the stock market. Others might not mind the risk and extra legwork of getting a loan and investing in a fund, so long as the potential return is substantial.  

There are a number of caveats that should be mentioned: First, past performance of the stock market isn’t a reliable indicator of future performance. Should the stock market nosedive, you could lose much of your investment, and you’ll still be on the hook for the $20,000 loan.

Also, consider the annual percentage rate on your loan carefully. The lower the APR, the more you’ll save over the life of a five-year loan. But again, there are no guarantees on how the stock market will perform. Even with a low APR, the risk of investing may not be worth it.

Check out the chart below to see how the APR could affect the potential savings, assuming the S&P 500 had a 10-year annualized rate of return of 7.7%.

Auto loan APR

Five-year potential savings












You could also decide to leave your $2,723 in the index fund for another five years. Of course, the value of your investment could fall, but assuming the 10-year annualized rate of return of 7.7%, that would bring it to $3,997. Stretch it to 20 years and it could grow to $12,639. That’s enough to pay for a lavish family vacation — or another car.

Victoria Simons is a senior analyst covering loans and insurance for NerdWallet.

This article originally appeared on Visit the original study here.

Comments are closed.


  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014


equity mortgage skimming telephone scam 104EZ 1st home 1st Mortgage 2nd Mortgage a partnering credit union account safety tips account security accounts anniversary anschutz ANSCHUTZ CAMPUS anschutz campus credit union anschutz credit union anschutz credit unions anschutz financial institution apps ATM atown AURORA aurora community Aurora Credit Union aurora credit unions auto auto loan auto loans AUTO PROMO auto promotions auto purchasing AUTO REFINANCE black friday borrow budget budgeting budgets building credit building teen credit business accounts buying a house buying a new car buying an old car calls car buying CAR DEALS car financing car refinance CARBUYING carbuying for teens Cardvalet cars CARS IN AURORA cars to fit your family checking Children savings accounts childrens hospital Childrens Hospital Colorado childrens miracle network childrenshospital CHRISTMAS MONEY christmas presents cmn college college affordability Colorado Comitis Crisis Center Community community credit union Community Involvement Aurora conserve corona Coronavirus COVID-19 credit credit building credit card credit history credit report credit score credit union Credit Union Leaders credit union strong Credit Unions for Kids credit unions in aurora CUNA cutting costs cybersecurity data breaches debt debt-payoff Denver Area Credit Union deposit diy do it yourself Dreams Thrive Here drive-in education Emergency Funds equifax Executive Team experien extra income Extrasbenefits Fin Lit finance a business finances financial education financial fit financial goals financial literacy Financial Literacy Classes financial mistakes financial planning Financial resources for parents FINANCIAL STABILITY financing your vacation finding the right car for you Fitzsimons fitzsimons army hospital fitzsimons credit union Fitzsimons Credit Union CEO fraud free credit report free tax help fun getting ready to move gift cards Giving Back goals Grocery Cart Races h&r block h&rblock health HELOC Helping the homeless hispanic outreach historic aurora history holiday accounts holiday budget HOLIDAY LOAN HOLIDAY SAVINGS holiday shopping' holidays home home banking home buyer Home buying HOME IMPROVEMENT home improvements home investing Home Loans home selling homebuying homebuying mistakes housing how to prepare house to be sold how to save money on auto loans identity identity theft ilovemycreditunion income tax income tax return insurance interest rates Internal revenue service International credit union day invest IRA IRS Juntos Avanzamos Juntoz Avanzamos Keller William:5280 Home Team kellerwilliams lastpass leasing a car library LikeABankButBetter line of creditt loan loans LOCAL Making a Difference making your money work for you member appreciation event. member benefits Millennials house mobile app mobile deposit money mortgage Mortgage Loan mortgage refinance moving my tax return national credit union month Nerdwallet Nest Egg new car new home new vs. old car NEW YEARS FINANCIAL RESOLOUTION new years resolution new years resolutioons online online learning and fun online safety online security Partnering Credit Union PEOPLE HELPING PEOPLE phone photo deposit ProtectMyID rainy day fun read realtor advice red rocks REFINANCE representative retirement ROTH IRA safety SandraNeves save SAVE FOR THE HOLIDAYS saving Saving for a vacation SAVING HABITS saving money SAVINGS savings for children savvy saver accounts scam Scam alerts Scholarship scholarship grants school security security breaches selling your home selling your house senator Small Business small business loans small houses smart savings smartphone southlands Southlands credit union spanish speaking stanley marketplace starting a business stolen identity student loans SUMMER SUMMER DEALS summer vacation taming the debt dragon TAX HELP tax prep software Tax refund Tax return tax season tax tips Taxes teachable moments teaching children about money teen accounts teen debit cards teen scholarships thanksgiving thanksgiving dinner This Is Aurora TOGETHER WE ADVANCE TURBOTAX university Updates used car used car loans Vacation vacation savings vacation tips VEHICLE REFINANCE Von Willebrand Disease VP of Finance wealth winter is coming WITHHOLDINGS Youth youth month youth savings accounts

Federally insured by NCUA |  Equal Opportunity Lender  |  © 2020 Fitzsimons Credit Union  |  303-340-3343  |  1-800-933-5839

Fitzsimons Credit Union recognizes the importance of ensuring our website is accessible to all users. We are in the process of redesigning our site in accordance with the requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and will be publishing updates to the website within the next several months so that our content is readable via non-graphical, text-only browsers. We appreciate your patience during this process. links to third party websites that may not be controlled or owned by Fitzsimons Credit Union. Fitzsimons Credit Union may not be responsible for the content of the alternate web site neither does it represent either the third party nor the member if the two enter into a transaction. Fitzsimons Credit Union does not represent either the third party or member if a transaction is entered. Privacy and security policies may differ from those practiced by

NMLS #459085
Shared Branch Logo  CO-OP ATM Logo Centennial Logo



AFF NCUA LogoEqual Housing Logo      

Please Note:

You are now leaving the Fitzsimons Credit Union website. We are not responsible for
the privacy practices of any other web site. We encourage you to read the privacy policies
of any web site you access, especially if individual identifying information is being collected.

Fitzsimons Credit Union does not represent either the third party or member if a transaction is entered.

Continue Cancel

Don't ask again